Home/Blog/Fulfillment
FulfillmentOperations

How to choose a 3PL: 12 questions to ask before you sign

Twelve questions that separate a reliable 3PL from a risky one, with the answers to look for on accuracy, pricing, technology, peak season and contract terms.

Flobox Editorial · 8 min read
How to choose a 3PL: 12 questions to ask before you sign

Choosing a 3PL is one of the few decisions an eCommerce brand makes that touches every single order. Get it right and fulfillment disappears into the background. Get it wrong and you spend a year answering "where is my order?" emails.

Sales calls all sound alike. These twelve questions do not. Ask each one, and ask for the answer in writing.

Performance

1. What is your order accuracy rate, and how do you measure it?

A strong answer is a specific number above 99.5% and an explanation: orders shipped without a picking or packing error, divided by total orders. A vague "very high" is a red flag. Flobox ships at 99.98% accuracy.

2. What is your same-day shipping cutoff?

Find out the exact time and what "shipped" means. The package should be scanned by the carrier that day, not just labeled. Our cutoff is 2 PM Eastern for same-day shipping.

3. How quickly do you receive inbound inventory?

Products that sit on the dock cannot be sold. Ask for the dock-to-stock time, the hours between a delivery arriving and its units being available to ship. Two business days or less is a healthy standard.

Pricing

4. Can you send me every billable line item?

Ask for the complete rate card, including setup, minimums, returns, special projects, and peak surcharges. Then price a real month of your orders against it. Our guide to 3PL pricing lists the fees that most often go unmentioned.

5. How do you choose a carrier for each package?

The right answer involves rate shopping: software that compares services on every shipment and picks the cheapest one that meets the delivery promise. Ask whether the negotiated rates are passed through to you.

6. What changes during peak season?

Carriers add surcharges in the fourth quarter, and some warehouses add their own. Ask for last year's peak fees and for the cutoff dates for inbound inventory before Black Friday.

Technology

7. Which sales channels do you integrate with natively?

Your store should connect in minutes. Ask to see the list, and ask specifically about every channel you sell on today and the ones you plan to add. Flobox connects to more than 100 stores, carts, and marketplaces.

8. What can I see in real time?

You should be able to log in and see inventory levels, order status, tracking numbers, and returns without emailing anyone. Ask for a live demo with real data, not screenshots.

Operations

9. How do you keep inventory accurate?

Look for cycle counting: counting a portion of the inventory every day rather than shutting down once a year. Ask what happens when a count does not match the system. Read more in inventory accuracy and cycle counting.

10. How do you handle returns?

Ask for the steps and the turnaround time. A return that takes three weeks to restock is inventory you cannot sell and a refund your customer is waiting for.

11. Who do I talk to when something goes wrong?

You want a named person and a response-time commitment, not a ticket queue. Ask who covers when that person is out.

Contract

12. What are the contract length and exit terms?

This question reveals the most. A provider confident in its service offers short terms and a clear exit. Watch for long lock-ins, automatic renewals, and fees to release your own inventory. Flobox works without long-term contracts.

How to score the answers

Give each answer zero, one, or two points:

  • Two points: a specific answer, in writing, with a number or a process behind it.
  • One point: a reasonable answer with no evidence.
  • Zero points: an evasive answer, or "why do you ask?"

A provider scoring 20 or more out of 24 runs a disciplined operation. Below 14, keep looking.

Two things no questionnaire can tell you

Visit the warehouse. In person or by video, look at the floor. Clean aisles, labeled locations, and calm workers tell you more than any slide. Chaos at 11 a.m. on a Tuesday will be worse in November.

Check the location against your customers. Map where your orders go. A provider with perfect answers and the wrong address will still cost you in transit time and shipping zones. If you sell to the East Coast or to Latin America, here is why Miami works as a fulfillment base.

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to switch 3PLs?

Plan for two to six weeks, depending on how much inventory you move and how many integrations you connect. Flobox can have inventory live in the warehouse in seven days from the moment it arrives.

Should I use one 3PL or several?

Start with one. A single well-located warehouse is simpler to manage and usually enough until your volume justifies splitting inventory across regions.

What is the biggest mistake when choosing a 3PL?

Choosing on the pick fee alone. Accuracy, location, and carrier rates have a larger effect on your total cost and on what your customers experience.

Ready to ship something?

Free fulfillment quote, no contract, no commitment. Inventory live in our Miami warehouse in 7 days.